Learning Center

Find the answers to your home improvement questions.

Is Hardwood Flooring Right For Me?

Child on hardwood floor

The choice of flooring in your home is crucial to your overall décor. Hardwood is a timeless classic that makes a definitive statement, but there are some things you should consider before making the decision, including how it will impact your family or workplace…and how your family or workplace will impact the floor. Let’s take a look at some of the positive and negative factors that will influence your hardwood flooring decision.

Advantages of Hardwood

When it comes to flooring, hardwood offers a lot of advantages and only a few disadvantages. It’s a healthy choice that looks and feels good, and it’s one of the most enduring flooring choices you can make.

Investment. Hardwood flooring is one of the few choices that will actually raise the value of your home and help it sell. Since hardwood floors are well known for retaining beauty, structural integrity and character for decades, they can be a powerfully persuasive selling point. The elegance and warmth of hardwood never goes out of style or wavers in its appeal. Whether you plan to keep your home for generations or sell it at a premium, hardwood flooring is always a good investment.

Warmth and comfort. Wood adds a warmth and elegance unparalleled by any other type of flooring. Traditionally considered a high-end material, hardwoods have lent an air of wealth, charm, and prestige to homes and buildings for centuries.

Even though they are a hard surface, hardwoods are warm and comfortable to walk on, even in the winter. They are easier on the feet and legs than tile or stone, making them more comfortable to walk and stand on all day. They fall somewhere in the middle on sound absorption, not completely absorbing sound, but not magnifying it either.

Due to the thickness of the planks, hardwoods can span slight inconsistencies in the floor better than many thinner laminate floors. Structurally, this makes hardwood feel solid and stable underfoot, without producing a hollow ring. This adds to the psychological component of perceived stability to a house, making it more desirable. As authentic and beautiful as most laminates and other floorings that imitate wood look, most people will know the difference immediately.

Design Variety. Unlike some laminate floors, in addition to varying thickness of the wood, planks can be purchase at varying lengths to achieve the look you want, making it instantly recognizable from common flooring and giving you a great deal of versatility of design.

There are dozens of species of hardwood to choose from, each with its own distinct grain, feel, hardness and natural color. Each type can be stained and finished to achieve the color that fits the look you envision. Finish can be smooth and glossy or more rustic, and can come pre-finished from the seller or unfinished to be finished after the floor is installed for a better seal against moisture from above. A site-finished floor may be a better option is moisture from above is a concern. Although installation will be more expensive, take longer and be messier, sealing the entire floor creates a barrier against moisture from above that can seep between the planks of a pre-finished floor. If going with a pre-finished hardwood floor, it is important to clean up spills quickly.

Durability. Properly cared for, hardwoods are some of the most durable types of flooring available. They can last a hundred years or more and be refinished as necessary to restore the original beauty.

Allergies. Hardwoods are a great choice for people with allergies. Dirt, dust, and hair cannot become trapped or embedded in the floor, so running a simple dust mop or vacuum over the floor will remove everything and keep the floor clean.

Disadvantages of Hardwood

There are only a few disadvantages to hardwood. The most significant factor to consider is moisture, including humidity. Another growing consideration is the environmental issue. Hardwoods harvested unethically destroy old-growth forests at an alarming rate. You can use your power as a consumer to ask the right questions, do the research, and refuse to buy undocumented hardwood or flooring that originates from a disreputable source and is not compliant with the Lacey Act. When considering longevity, ethically harvested and manufactured hardwood can be a green and sustainable choice.

Price. This may seem confusing, but the price of hardwood is both a pro and a con. Hardwood can be very pricey compared to some other types of flooring, which means your initial out-of-pocket costs are significant. However, most flooring won’t last longer than 25 years at best, and some, for example carpet, won’t even last that long. The extended lifespan of hardwood, which can be refinished (unless it becomes badly warped or irreparably damaged) or replaced in sections if necessary, makes hardwood an economical choice when amortized over the life of the floor. Some high-end engineered floorings cost more than hardwoods, but installation may be higher, depending on whether you plan to do it yourself or hire professionals and whether you choose pre-finished or unfinished wood. One thing it certain, however, in 20 years or less, it will cost less to maintain a beautiful hardwood than to replace worn-out carpet.

Wearability. Hardwood is vulnerable to moisture, scratches, and impacts – and may require vigilance for people with pets and children. The simplest solution to impacts from dropped objects or scratches from pet claws is the use of non-slip rugs to protect the high traffic areas.

Moisture. Moisture is the number one problem with hardwood flooring. Wood swells when moist or wet, which is why your doors may be harder to open at certain times of year. The same will happen to the floor, only there’s nowhere to go, so excessive moisture can cause the floor to buckle, crack, or warp. Solid hardwood flooring is not recommended for installations below grade where moisture may seep up from the ground, for locations with extreme changes in humidity or for high moisture areas such as bathrooms.

Installing hardwoods in a climate with high humidity can be done if proper precautions are taken. Woods thicker than 5/16” – 5/8” should not be installed directly over concrete, and a subfloor with a moisture barrier installed will help combat ground moisture. Sufficient expansion room should be left around the floor edges, covered by trim or molding. While some hardwood flooring can be a DIY project with easy tongue-and-groove installation, you may want to consider hiring a professional to ensure the proper moisture control and expansion space for the optimal lifespan of your floor. Mistakes can prove costly.

Locations. Hardwood should never be installed in rooms where standing water is common, like bathrooms. If installed in a kitchen or wet bar area, wet spills should be dried immediately. In an entryway, a rug or runner will help absorb moisture from rain or snow.

(9) Comments

  1. Pingback: David Weekley offering its first tours of roomy townhomes in Lakewood’s Belmar … – The Denver Post | eegbusiness

  2. I live on a canal in the New Orleans area and would like to put hard wood flooring down on my sub floor. My house is built on pilings 15′ high. My dogs are active. I want to put in LR. What do you suggest?

    • Hi Clare,

      Both solid hardwood and engineered floors can work well in a kitchen, keeping in mind that moisture and acidic substances like wine and sauces can prove to be potentially problematic if left too long on the surface of a wood floor. Some runners and floor mats can help you get around the problem of spills, although damp rugs and runners should not be left to sit, either.

      Beyond that, solid hardwood tends to be priced higher than most engineered floors. This is because more natural material is used, and because many solid wood floors also add a layer of structural strength to a property. Saying that, engineered floors are highly practical in their own ways, particularly when it comes to temperature variations, which are pretty common in kitchens.

      I hope that helps!

  3. Wanting to put hardwood in foyer, den and kitchen areas. Given the fact that a kitchen usually has spills/moisture issues, is there a hardwood you would recommend?

  4. I have a dance studio which has a tile floor. I need to replace it Would A hardwood floor stan the taps?

  5. I want to use for professional ballroom dancing floor,what type the floor should use for non scratch and durable

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You can use these HTML tags and attributes <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.